Review: War Horse is Traditional, Sentimental

“I, Albert Narracott, do solemnly swear that we shall be together again.”

War Horse easily ranks as one of my most anticipated films this year. Since reading the book by Michael Morpurgo back in February, I looked forward to seeing Steven Spielberg’s big screen treatment of the WWI-era story.

Performances by the largely unknown cast are overly dramatic at times, reminding me of stage acting or the earlier days of cinema. Lead Jeremy Irvine as Albert and supporting actors Tom Hiddleston (Captain Nicholls) and Niels Arestrup (unnamed grandfather) are strongest in their roles.

Spielberg’s tone for the film is heavily traditional throughout, at times to a fault. From Janusz Kaminski’s cinematography to John Williams’ score, this movie could have been made years ago. Some will appreciate this, others will not. I was caught square in the middle myself—no man’s land, you might say.

It’s the expertly crafted WWI battle scenes that are the film’s forte. That is where Spielberg is most in his element and it shows. And the Great War is not just pivotal for its action, but for what it means for the characters.

Most war films illustrate man’s inhumanity towards man; War Horse adds man’s inhumanity towards beast. When equine protagonist Joey gets entrapped in barbed wire after running through the fighting, he seems to be asking, “Why?”

Fans of the book will be happy to find this War Horse mostly faithful to its source, except for the disappointing exclusion of one of the book’s most heart-rending parts, Joey’s bout with tetanus. (I’ve since learned this is not in the stage play, which I have yet to see, either.)

My view is that War Horse will be perceived very differently by different individuals. Many of the choices I found questionable, others will find no fault with. Whatever conclusion you come to, you have to respect Spielberg for making exactly the movie he wanted to.

War Horse opens in theatres on Sunday. It is one of two Steven Spielberg-directed films released in North America this weekend, the other being the motion capture-animated Adventures of Tintin. I found it to be “surprisingly fantastic”.

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)

About Mike Bastoli

Mike Bastoli has been blogging at The Disney Blog since 2009. Until 2011, he covered Pixar Animation Studios on his own website, The Pixar Blog, which became one of the most popular on the Web dedicated to Pixar news, the New York Times calling it the “definitive unofficial chronicler of the animation powerhouse". In 2011, Mike expanded his coverage to the entire world of feature animation, renaming his site Big Screen Animation. He retired Big Screen Animation in 2014 and is considering future writing opportunities. Besides Disney, Mike is an avid fan of Apple and The Beatles. He resides near Toronto.
This entry was posted in Movies and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Review: War Horse is Traditional, Sentimental

  1. Pingback: The Disney Blog

Comments are closed.