The Star Wars universe is still reeling from the death of Carrie Fisher on December 27. Her passing has left a great disturbance in The Force as Fisher, in her role as General Leia Organa, was set to appear in both Episodes VIII and IX.
General Organa originally had a larger role in “The Force Awakens” but part of it ended up on the cutting room floor. In Episode VIII, which is in post-production now, it was important that her role be expanded (it’s likely that she and Luke have a reunion as she continued to run The Resistance) and was expected to have even larger role in Episode IX as she and Luke confronted her son Ben, aka Kylo Ren.
It’s being widely reported that the story trust at Lucasfilm will be meeting with Colin Trevorrow and Derek Connolly, who are writing the script for Star Wars Episode IX (Trevorrow is also directing), on January 10th to discuss options on what do do with the character of General Leia Organa. The role of Leia, of course, was originated by Fisher who played the Star Wars princess, senator, and general in four Star Wars movies. Fisher’s death has left many people grieving, including the folks at Lucasfilm some of whom had worked closely with her at one point or another.
Now they have to figure out what to do. Episode IX is scheduled to start shooting in early 2019, so they have time to figure out the optimum path.
But what will that path look like? Some of the options they could explore:
1) Digitally insert Fisher into the movie
2) Re-cast the role
3) Write the character out of the film
Option one would be to reduce the role of General Organa in Episode IX, giving some of her scenes and lines to another character (a new character or perhaps Rey or Billie Lourd’s character). For the scenes where Leia is required, use a combination of existing unused footage (I’m sure there’s quite a bit from the two episodes they’ve already filmed), some CGI magic like they did with Grand Moff Tarkin in Rogue One, and stand-ins filmed from behind, to work around the actresses death.
There’s the matter if this is the most respectful to Carrie Fisher’s memory or not. Would audiences accept seeing the character on screen for an actor they know is dead? The did it in “Furious 7” when Paul Walker died mid-way through filming. So it is possible.
Option two would be to just recast General Organa. This is a tradition in Hollywood. James “Rhodey” Rhodes was recast in the Iron Man trilogy from Marvel with Don Cheadle replacing Terrance Howard. Katie Holmes was replaced by Maggie Gyllenhall in Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight trilogy. Even Jennifer Parker in the Back to the Future Trilogy was recast when Claudia Wells decided she needed to care for her ill mother. Elisabeth Shue stepped in and even refilmed the closing scene for Back to the Future shot-for-shot for the opening of Back to the Future 2.
Would it be easy? No. Carrie Fisher has been iconic in the Princess Leia role. Her wit, strength, and style would be hard to recast. Anyone who did step into the role, would undoubtedly put their own touch on the character, changing her. Fans may not be able to abide.
Option three is to write the Organa Character out of the trilogy. In this scenario they would make subtle changes in Episode VIII by changing a line here or adding a scene there to imply some sort of growing threat to General Organa (Bounty Hunters, perhaps?). Then they would write an Opening Crawl for Episode IX that deals with the off-screen death of Leia. Something like this:
“The forces of THE RESISTANCE are still recovering from [the events of Episode VIII]. General Organa was elected new President of the new Republic only to be assassinated by the evil forces of THE FIRST ORDER.
Now a small band of spies and fighters led by the Jedi Master Luke Skywalker take on a final mission that will decide the fate of the galaxy, but first they mourn the loss of Leia…”
The movie opens with President Organa’s funeral and then Luke, Rey, and Finn get on the Millennium Falcon and take off on their adventure.
Writing General Organa out of Episode IX is not ideal, but having her die would give some extra motive for the characters that remain to defeat the First Order.
It’s hard to think about an Episode IX without Princess Leia, but the point of doing this third trilogy has been to hand off the franchise from the old guard (Han, Leia, Luke) to the new (Rey, Finn, Poe). It’s unlikely Leia and Luke would have been featured in future films in the Star Wars universe.
Which option do you think is the best for dealing with the role of General Leia Organa now that Carrie Fisher has tragically died?
(2015 Comic-Con Photo courtesy Disney by Jesse Grant/Getty Images)
option 3 would not be subtle; she’s a central character pivotal to these stories and obviously set up in VIII to have even more to do in IX. That’s a big problem that would need a major rewrite and leave a big hole in story/character resolution
First, RIP Carrie! Regrettably optio three is the best. Number one COULD work if CGI does a good job. It would be a fitting tribute to her. Number two; uh-uh! No recast. Look how Batman suffered after Keaton left. The movies sucked! Nothing that’s done will ever replace our Princess Leia but three and one are the best.
It needs to be a combination on Option 1 and Option 3. Use deleted and unused scenes to help set up action, use a double to film a scene from the back and then go to Option 3 out of respect.
I think the best way to honor Carrie Fisher here would be to keep Leia in Episode IX, however they have to do it. I think the technology to digitally recreate her might be advanced enough by the time they start post-production on it (a couple of years from now), so it might be possible to include her fully in the story. Use a body double for filming, morph Carrie Fisher’s face onto the body double, and use a voice double for the dialogue. Sure, it’d be expensive, but it’ll be but a tiny fraction of the billions that Episode IX is likely to pull in.
I truly believe Carrie Fisher would want the story to remain unaltered, with Leia’s role fully realized, rather than having her written out or severely diminished.
This is going to be a difficult task being that Carrie Fisher IS Princess Leia. I would be ok with a CGI option if it were well done and limited strictly to necessity. Limiting Leia’s role should be considered. Star Wars is filled with Holograms, there could be hologram cgi which would make some scenes less difficult to swallow, and minimum live action CGI to finish what has already been planned in the storyline. If a Leia Kylo Ren emotional reunion is planned, this could be the most difficult scenario to create and should be done with care. I would not like to see Leia re-cast, but killing her off is also a difficulty since episode 7 dipped it’s foot in that pool. #MayTheForceBeWithThoseWriters