Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it’s a small world for 40 minutes

I’ve been stuck on It’s A Small World (IASW) a couple times before, once for 26 minutes. Let me tell you, it was not a pleasant experience. The music never turned off while other boats were being evacuated around us. Alas, we were stuck in a bad spot and by the time they got to us, the ride had been fixed and we were allowed to finish the ride. Thankfully, this was during the holiday makeover for the ride, so there was at least a little musical variation, but it was still fairly close to intolerable after about the first 10 minutes.

Still, it never crossed my mind to sue over the experience (instead I wrote an epic poem, true story). One man who spent 40 minutes stuck on the doll filled journey, decided that a lawsuit was required. What was different in our situations, besides the additional 14 minutes, was that the man is a quadriplegic and was riding in the wheelchair accessible vehicle. He claims that other vehicles were unloaded before his was and that it was due to his status as disabled. He also claims that Disney has no proper procedure for unloading disabled in event of an emergency.

I admit I am not familiar with Disneyland’s current policies as regards the loading, unloading, or emergency evacuation of passengers (disabled or not) on various attractions. And I am not familiar with the exact wording in the manual for operations of IASW. But I have read similar manuals and policies in the past (and both the Monorail and Space Mountain manual just last month). So here’s my take.

The Americans with Disability Act puts Disney parks in a bit of hard place when it comes to accommodating disabled passengers on attractions. Disney must make an effort to accommodate wheelchair passengers where possible, but it can require that you must be able to transfer to ride certain attractions. Disney often stretches this rule by allowing you to travel with a companion who could assist you in the event of a ride evacuation. The 16 year old boy or girl who is evacuating you from the top of the Matterhorn or even it’s a small world is not capable, not should they really be asked to, lift or transfer anyone during a ride evacuation. So having a companion is important. There are a lot of stairs and narrow walkways when descending from the Matterhorn and there are a few stairs and narrow walkways when evacuating IASW too. That 16 year old has to worry about the safety of all passengers in their zone.

Now the same thing applies when being evacuated from any building with stairs. Someone in a wheelchair would require assistance being evacuated. I took a course when I worked in a skyscraper in Downtown LA and eventually earned my CERT certification. The policy the Los Angeles Fire Department and CERT program recommended was that in event of an evacuation someone be designated to wait with the disabled person on a stair landing until Fire & Rescue arrives to assist with an evacuation.

I’m sure you can see some problems with that. If the building was on fire or other immediate danger existed, I would think that the kindness of strangers and co-workers would kick in and someone would help those who could not evacuate on their own. But if it’s just a drill or a nonlethal threat, it might make more sense to wait in place rather than risk injury to the disabled or those trying to assist them. My guess is that is how Disneyland’s policy reads.

So I am very sorry that the gentleman had to wait while others evacuated ahead of him. But due to the nature of the attraction and the lack of a real emergency, remaining in place and not risking injury to him or the cast members is the action recommended by CERT and the Fire Department and hopefully by Disney as well.

No word if the gentleman had to endure the soundtrack for the entire length of his captivity. Now that would be worth a lawsuit for mental stress.

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)
This entry was posted in Disneyland and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it’s a small world for 40 minutes

  1. j says:

    the real issue in this lies in the access from boats and carts within the rides for those in wheel chairs. we’ve already seen lap bars and railings added to rides out of similar situations arising, or simply the possibility of a situation arising. the possible effects of this could leave disney in a very tight place, changing rides like small world and pirates of the caribbean at risk of closure or serious changes.

    i’m all for accessibility for all and equal safety for all, but when it comes to disabilities and the authenticity of a ride or experience tough calls need to be made. do we ensure everyone has the same access and de-access to a ride hindering it’s quality. or do we focus on the quality and overall build experience of a ride or show and leave some out. this is going to be a tough one.

    oh and i highly doubt disney deliberately left him last because he was in a wheelchair.

  2. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  3. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  4. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  5. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  6. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  7. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  8. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  9. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  10. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  11. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  12. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  13. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b

  14. Pingback: Alltop Disney

  15. Man sues Disneyland after being stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes http://bit.ly/dUuR3b what is your record?

  16. Disney Girl says:

    We had to evacuate one of my rides today, and we also had a guest in a wheelchair on the ride. The reason it takes so long to evacuate guests in wheelchairs–the reason it took us so long *and* the reason it took so long for Small World–is because we cast members are not allowed to evacuate those guests. It has to do with safety and personal liability. We could possibly injure the guests and ourselves in the process of lifting them out of the wheelchair and/or ride vehicle, and then the guest might even sue us.

    Instead, Disney’s policy is for Reedy Creek, our own emergency services a la 911, to evacuate these guests. As soon as we know we have to evacuate, we call Reedy Creek. However, while they are on property, they don’t just sit around in the tunnels waiting for a possible emergency. It does take them a while to reach the location of the evacuation, so while everyone else might be evacuated by that time, the guest in the wheelchair cannot be evacuated until Reedy Creek shows up.

    I cannot say why it took 40 minutes at Small World as I do not work on that ride, but I’m sure it has to do with waiting for Reedy Creek to arrive and all available cast members busy evacuating the other guests–which can take time given the set up of Small World. While I am sorry the guest was upset over his experience, I don’t believe he has a case.

  17. Man stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes sues Disneyland http://bit.ly/dUuR3b How long before you would sue?

  18. mike gunthner says:

    I can not believe there were mental trama from staying on the ride for 40 mins, I’m a disabled person with cerebal palsy and planning to visit walt disney world with my son, who have the nerve to sue disney, the ambelance chasers grab at that chance.

  19. Kevin Cantor says:

    Wow. RT @TheDisneyBlog Man stuck on it's a small world for 40 minutes sues Disneyland http://bit.ly/dUuR3b How long before you would sue?

  20. Aaron says:

    Do a bit of research before claiming him a shyster looking for a quick buck or claiming he has no case. The man had spinal issues that when he was placed in a high stress situation, like being trapped on a ride with no ETA of rescue, cause him to go into a shock like state. It’s only made worse by being IASW of all things. The repetitive music, lights, and movement of the environment can cause a seizure like state if under enough stress and cause suffocation in afflicted persons if left unsupervised.

    I think if IASW ever breaks down, they need to shut that horrible song off if the ride cannot be repaired in under 5 minutes.

    I’m not championing him to win his case, but I think you ought to be more considerate to those who do not handle stress well. I think anyone with PTSD would probably also suffer a similar reaction, but you wouldn’t give that person grief, would you?

Comments are closed.